Top rated totally unbelievable movies on Shudder

Check out today’s highest ranked totally unbelievable movies on Shudder! Looking for the greatest movies of all times? Here is the list of the best totally unbelievable movies on Shudder, based on the crowd's interest and popular searches from the country.

1 Speak No Evil (2022)

A Danish family visits a Dutch family they met on a holiday. What was supposed to be an idyllic weekend slowly starts unraveling as the Danes try to stay polite in the face of unpleasantness.

Info

2022-03-17 | Drama / Horror

Cast

Morten Burian, Sidsel Siem Koch

Rating

rating icon 6.593
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    maddening
  2. Ranked #1 for
    unreasonable character
  3. Ranked #1 for
    feeling uneasy

Trailer

Speak No Evil trailer
play button

2 The Reckoning (2021)

In the aftermath of the Great Plague and amidst the subsequent witch-hunts against women, a young widow grapples with the tragic death of her husband in a society completely consumed by fear and death. Because she rejects the advances of her landlord, she is falsely accused of being a witch and thrown in jail for a crime she didn’t commit. She must endure physical persecution at the hands of England’s most ruthless witch-hunter and face her own inner demons as the devil himself starts to work his way into her mind.

Info

2021-02-05 | Horror / Drama

Cast

Charlotte Kirk, Sean Pertwee

Rating

rating icon 6.6
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    late night movie
  2. Ranked #1 for
    tepid plot
  3. Ranked #2 for
    grim tale

Trailer

The Reckoning trailer
play button

3 Peninsula (2020)

A soldier and his team battle hordes of post-apocalyptic zombies in the wastelands of the Korean Peninsula.

Info

2020-07-15 | Horror / Adventure

Cast

Gang Dong-won, Lee Jung-hyun

Rating

rating icon 6.769
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    different
  2. Ranked #1 for
    slightly inferior
  3. Ranked #3 for
    too much CG

Trailer

Peninsula trailer
play button

4 Color Out of Space (2019)

The Gardner family moves to a remote farmstead in rural New England to escape the hustle of the 21st century. They are busy adapting to their new life when a meteorite crashes into their front yard, melts into the earth, and infects both the land and the properties of space-time with a strange, otherworldly colour. To their horror, the family discovers this alien force is gradually mutating every life form that it touches—including them.

Info

2019-09-07 | Horror / Science Fiction

Cast

Nicolas Cage, Joely Richardson

Rating

rating icon 6.019
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    otherworldly
  2. Ranked #1 for
    spaced out character
  3. Ranked #1 for
    Cosmic Horror

Trailer

Color Out of Space trailer
play button
download maimovie
Download
Maimovie Now

to discover other
796 similar movies

5 The Mortuary Collection (2020)

In the phantasmagorical town of Raven's End, a misguided young girl takes refuge in a decrepit old mortuary. The eccentric undertaker chronicles the strange history of the town through a series of twisted tales, each more terrifying than the last, but the young girl's world is unhinged when she discovers that the final story... is her own.

Info

2020-10-08 | Fantasy / Horror

Cast

Clancy Brown, Caitlin Custer

Rating

rating icon 6.747
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    nice
  2. Ranked #1 for
    morbid
  3. Ranked #1 for
    entertaining ride

Trailer

The Mortuary Collection trailer
play button

6 A Good Woman Is Hard to Find (2019)

The recently widowed mother of two, Sarah, is desperate to know who murdered her husband in front of her young son, rendering him mute. Coerced into helping a low-life drug dealer stash narcotics stolen from the local Mr. Big, she's forced into taking drastic action to protect her children, evolving from downtrodden submissive to take-charge vigilante.

Info

2019-10-25 | Thriller / Crime

Cast

Sarah Bolger, Edward Hogg

Rating

rating icon 6.092
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    different approach
  2. Ranked #2 for
    perfectly watchable
  3. Ranked #2 for
    unique approach

Trailer

A Good Woman Is Hard to Find trailer
play button

7 Come True (2020)

Looking for an escape from her recurring nightmares, 18-year-old Sarah submits to a university sleep study, but soon realizes she's become the conduit to a frightening new discovery.

Info

2020-09-24 | Science Fiction / Horror

Cast

Julia Sarah Stone, Landon Liboiron

Rating

rating icon 5.966
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    groggy
  2. Ranked #1 for
    tense atmosphere
  3. Ranked #1 for
    ambient music

Trailer

Come True trailer
play button

8 Take Back the Night (2022)

Finding herself the victim of a violent monster attack, Jane launches a vigilante campaign to hunt the beast that tried to kill her. Jane's efforts intensify, but her troubling history of drug use and mental illness bubbles to the surface causing her family, community, and authorities to question the authenticity of her account. Suddenly alone in her fight, Jane starts to doubt her own memory of the attack...to doubt if Monster exists at all.

Info

2022-03-04 | Horror

Cast

Emma Fitzpatrick, Jennifer Lafleur

Rating

rating icon 4.2
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    director with promising future
  2. Ranked #1 for
    well-endowed
  3. Ranked #1 for
    half-ass

Trailer

Take Back the Night trailer
play button

9 Son (2021)

When a young boy contracts a mysterious illness, his mother must decide how far she will go to protect him from terrifying forces in her past.

Info

2021-03-18 | Horror / Thriller

Cast

Andi Matichak, Emile Hirsch

Rating

rating icon 5.99
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    unspeakable act
  2. Ranked #2 for
    unchallenging
  3. Ranked #2 for
    ambiguous ending

Trailer

Son trailer
play button

10 Tailgate (2019)

A cocksure, road-raging family man finds himself pursued and terrorized by the vengeful van driver he chooses to tailgate.

Info

2019-10-31 | Thriller / Horror

Cast

Jeroen Spitzenberger, Anniek Pheifer

Rating

rating icon 6.2
More Info

People's Taste Ranking

  1. Ranked #1 for
    like Cape Fear
  2. Ranked #1 for
    totally unrealistic
  3. Ranked #1 for
    belligerent

Trailer

Tailgate trailer
play button

FAQ

According to the review analysis on Maimovie, movies in Top rated totally unbelievable movies on Shudder list are rated as ticked off, utterly stupid, illogical decision, unholy, chintzy, berserk, catatonic, perfectly watchable, genuinely unsettling, unhappy ending.
We collect all existing reviews on the web for all movies and proceed machine learning to calculate the A.I. ranking. It ranks the movies while automatically updating new information every week.
Using Taste search, Maimovie provides a unique system which helps you search for specific results through phrases that are collected from movie reviews and information from various movie databases. You can look for movies with phrases such as “adrenaline pumping movies” or “unexpected plot twist of all time.” The Maimovie application’s database covers movie information from all 540K+ movies and connects you to all 74+ available streaming services.